Dear magic judge, I hope this message finds you in good health and high spirits. I am writing to seek your guidance and expertise on a matter that has been perplexing me for quite some time. As a novice in the realm of magic, I find myself confronted with various challenges and uncertainties. It is during these instances that I realize the true significance of having a knowledgeable and experienced mentor like yourself. Your vast understanding of the intricacies of magic has inspired me to reach out and request your assistance in unraveling the enigma before me. In my quest to deepen my magical abilities, I have encountered spells and incantations that have left me utterly astounded.
In my quest to deepen my magical abilities, I have encountered spells and incantations that have left me utterly astounded. Although I have dedicated a considerable amount of time to studying the ancient texts and scrolls, there are still certain aspects that elude me. It is in such moments of bewilderment that I realize the importance of having a magic judge on hand to offer insight and guidance.
When should a judge intervene in a match?
I started judging at Regular last week, and one thing that made me uncomfortable was watching players break rules. Sometimes the opponent would look at me like, "Are you really going to let this happen?" I tried my best to educate the players without providing an unfair advantage or being a pesky judge who intervenes every thirty seconds, but I'd rather have a set of official rules that I can follow so that I know when to intervene. For example, one player declared an attacker, the opponent declared a blocker, then the first player declared another attacker, and then the opponent looked to me for intervention. Not sure if I should intervene, I decided to ask the player, "Do you have a question?" He took the bait, and I was able to correct the situation and educate the players on how declaring attackers works. When should I intervene in a match?
- magic-the-gathering
'Sometimes the opponent would look at me like, "Are you really going to let this happen?"' If this is actually occurring, you should let players know that they should call a judge to fix errors in the game and that at Competitive REL, taking advantage of an opponent's errors (that aren't missing triggers) can be UC-Cheating.
Jul 16, 2015 at 17:57@HaoYe Absolutely. I should have reminded players to speak up when they have a question. I'm a little crowd-shy, so I approached the problem by leaning in asking the players directly, "Do you have a question?" I think it worked well, but an announcement would have been better.
Jul 16, 2015 at 18:06Do you have an example? You should never allow an actual violation of game rules to go uncorrected. Two matches later they try it again and say "Well last time the judge was looking right at it and didn't say anything" and now both they and their opponent think that's how the game is played. The amount of "Sloppy Play" that ultimately leads to legal game states that is tolerated at Regular is maybe more flexible.
Jul 16, 2015 at 21:56Your role as a magic judge carries immense weight and importance. Not only are you responsible for interpreting the rules and regulations that govern the magical realm, but you also possess the unique ability to settle disputes and provide clarity in the face of uncertainty. Your expertise and judgment serve as a beacon of wisdom, guiding those of us who are still navigating the intricate world of magic. I come before you today with a burning question that has been gnawing at the depths of my mind. Is it possible for a beginner like myself to harness the power of advanced spells without compromising my safety or that of others? I find myself drawn to the allure of these potent incantations, yet fear the consequences of unleashing forces beyond my control. Your guidance on this matter would be invaluable to me. I trust in your judgment, and I have the utmost faith that your advice will lead me down the path of responsible and ethical magical practices. Your words, shaped by years of experience and wisdom, will undoubtedly shape my approach to harnessing the power that lies within. In conclusion, I wish to express my heartfelt gratitude for your availability and willingness to be a guiding light in the realm of magic. Your role as a magic judge is pivotal in upholding the integrity of our craft and ensuring the safety of practitioners. I eagerly await your response and look forward to the enlightening clarity and guidance you will provide. Yours sincerely, [Your Name].
Reviews for "Breaking Down the Banlist: Ask a Magic Judge about Card Restrictions"
- Sarah - 2/5 - I was really disappointed with "Ask a magic judge". The concept sounded interesting, but I found the execution to be lacking. The magic judge seemed more interested in promoting their own agenda and showing off their knowledge than actually providing valuable advice. I also found the format of the show to be confusing and disorganized. Overall, I didn't feel like I got the help or information I was looking for from this podcast.
- John - 1/5 - I couldn't stand "Ask a magic judge". The host was condescending and dismissive towards the callers' questions. It felt like they were trying to show off their superiority and belittle anyone who didn't already have extensive knowledge of magic rules. I didn't feel welcomed or encouraged to ask my own questions, and I certainly didn't get any useful answers from this podcast.
- Emily - 2/5 - "Ask a magic judge" was a letdown for me. I expected to learn more about the technical aspects of magic and get some insider knowledge, but instead, it felt like a show full of inside jokes and irrelevant tangents. The host seemed more interested in entertaining themselves and their regular listeners rather than providing helpful content for newbies like me. The format was also confusing, with constant interruptions and distractions. I wouldn't recommend this podcast to anyone looking for serious and informative discussions about magic.